Differences
This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
| Both sides previous revisionPrevious revisionNext revision | Previous revision | ||
| utsfl:classroom:infographic [2014/07/05 11:36] – integrated old notes with Rebecca's structure; emphasized key rhetorical steps to move from each level balleyne | utsfl:classroom:infographic [2014/07/05 12:01] (current) – FIXMEs for forcing the cold-blooded to bite the bullet or step down balleyne | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
| - Relate: Find Common Ground | - Relate: Find Common Ground | ||
| - Recount: Use an analogy (to trot out the toddler) | - Recount: Use an analogy (to trot out the toddler) | ||
| - | - Remind: ask what's the difference | + | - //Remind: ask what's the difference?// |
| - | * core pro-life argument / justification line / difficult life circumstances lin | + | * core pro-life argument / justification line / difficult life circumstances lin |
| - [Biology] Not human((D)) | - [Biology] Not human((D)) | ||
| * **Three Question apologetic** | * **Three Question apologetic** | ||
| - If something is growing, isn't it alive? | - If something is growing, isn't it alive? | ||
| - | - If something has human parents, is it human offspring? | + | - If something has human parents, is it human offspring? |
| - | - Human beings have human rights, don't they? | + | * fertilization; |
| - | * biology of prenatal development | + | * unique whole human life |
| - | * fertilization; | + | * composition / behaviour |
| - | * unique whole human life | + | * gamete vs. organism (("if you give a sperm (vs. zygote) everything it needs to live, what will happen?" |
| - | * composition / behaviour | + | - //Human beings have human rights, don't they?// |
| - | * gamete vs. organism (("if you give a sperm (vs. zygote) everything it needs to live, what will happen?" | + | |
| - [Personhood] Human, but...((C)) | - [Personhood] Human, but...((C)) | ||
| * **Personhood = human + X** => definition of a grave violation human rights | * **Personhood = human + X** => definition of a grave violation human rights | ||
| - | * SLED => age discrimination | + | |
| + | | ||
| - [1st premise objections] Then, okay, human person but right to life can be trumped by... bodily autonomy or mother' | - [1st premise objections] Then, okay, human person but right to life can be trumped by... bodily autonomy or mother' | ||
| + | * FIXME what are the quick steps to force them to bite the bullet on difficult situations? | ||
| FIXME import June 25 sketch | FIXME import June 25 sketch | ||
| inspiration: | inspiration: | ||